This timeless piece (which means I got to it over a year late) shows the similarities between Jews and Christians in holding onto the essence of ritual without getting swept away in the push for etertainment and "relevance."
My son William was recently invited to his friend Josh's bar mitzva. William had never been to a bar mitzva before, and he's still talking about it. The invitation was a video tape of Josh, dressed like the Terminator and doing an Arnold Schwarzenegger impression: "Come to my bar mitzva, or else!"
When I dropped William off at the five-star hotel ballroom, everything was decorated to look like metal. There were robots standing guard with blinking eyes and moving arms; destroyed tanks and cars strewn about (rented from a movie prop house); and inflatable jungle gyms and slides, all in camouflage colors. There was even a life-sized Arnold Schwarzenegger cutout for guests to sign.
After the aliya latorah, Josh made his grand entrance on a "T2" motorcycle - his bar mitzva gift from his parents! Following the motzi, a live rock band played modern techno music. Josh did a really cool robot dance. During the traditional candlelighting ceremony, Josh lit 13 candles with a butane lighter shaped like a Terminator rifle. My son wished he could take it home with him.
Many of our children--goyim though they be--are invited to bar (and bat) mitzvas in middle school, which provide interesting views into modern (more liberal) Jewish life. They usually emerge after hours of fun with trinkets, personalised clothes, shades, and heaps of party favours--all of which makes the actual ritual itself bearable. (Some families allow their kids to skip the synagogue and go directly to the party, which is mistifying.)
It is reminiscent of our attempts to make the sacraments "fun" or worse, lavishly competitive. There are even those who will postpone the sacraments until enough money is saved for the right reception or until the bride can fit into a slinky dress (post-partem). In Equador, a family I met didn't baptise their daughter, knowing they couldn't afford the chickens necessary to feed the extended family, so they were going to wait for another child and hope to manage a two-fer.
The short-term goal, for parents, is often to make rituals fit into our lives with minimal spiritual discomfort, although the irony is that the mundane trials become even more traumatic. After planning her own son's bar mitzvah began to reach crisis mode, the mother
made a dash for my bookshelf to retrieve my dog-eared copy of the Book of Jewish Values to see what the ever wise and rational Rabbi Joseph Telushkin might have to say about the situation. He didn't let me down.
"Out of the desire not to appear cheap or unloving to their children, many... Jews feel forced to spend far more on [bar mitzva] parties than they can or want to," he writes. "Furthermore lavish parties often end up diminishing, sometimes even eliminating, the religious significance of the bar mitzva. For many of the celebrants, what counts is the 'bar,' not the mitzva."
What we desperately need, says Telushkin, are some "wealthy moral heroes... prominent, affluent Jews in our largest Jewish communities - to throw a simple bar or bat mitzva celebration, one in which the party is very pleasant and celebratory, but not lavish." In doing so, he holds, "the good they would do for their fellow Jews would be almost incalculable."
Thank you Rabbi Telushkin! The same goes for Christian weddings, where the warantees on the piles of gifts often outlast the actual unions. Kids may enjoy Terminator rifle candle lighters, but the flame itself is often overpowered by the schtick. Mothers--as keepers of the flame and builders of culture--would do well to be the moral heroes and teach children that ritual is often meant to be sacrifice. If it is pleasing to God, then He'll provide the reward, not Arnold.
Recent Comments